Casting de Falling in Love Again

Elliott Gould

Harry Lewis (Present Day)

Susannah York

Sue Lewis (Present Day)

Kaye Ballard

Mrs. Lewis (1940's)

Stuart Paul

'Pompadoure' (Young Harry Lewis) (1940's)

Michelle Pfeiffer

Sue Wellington (1940's)

Robert Hackman

Mr. Lewis (1940's)

Herbert Rudley

Mr. Wellington (1940's)

Marian McCargo

Mrs. Wellington (1940's)

Steven Paul

Stan the Con (1940's)

Tallie Cochrane

Hooker (Present Day)

Patrick Wright

Pat the Cop (1940's)

Bonnie Paul

Hilary Lewis (Present Day)

Tony O'Dell

Donny Lewis (Present Day)

Ben Frank

Cabbie #1 (Present Day)

John Diehl

Beaver (1940's)

David Caruso

Neighborhood boy (uncredited)

Pete Schrum

Meatloaf (Present Day)

Marvin Katzoff

Como (1940's)

Alan Solomon

Max the Brain (1940's)

Daniel Davies

Meatloaf (1940's)

Mickey Cherney

Ben Herman (1940's)

Mort Schwartz

Hymie the Bookie (1940's)

Al Bordighi

Como's Father (1940's)

Twink Caplan

Malinda (1940's)

Shel Goldstein

Scrap Drive Leader - 1940's